Gold and S&P 500 Peaking Together 6 Times in 2025 — A 1970s Echo of Financial Chaos?
Gold and S&P 500 Peaking Together 6 Times in 2025 — A 1970s Echo of Financial Chaos?
Daniela Cambone: 10-7-2025
In finance, conventional wisdom often holds that when stocks soar, safe havens like gold languish. They are supposed to be inverse reflections of economic confidence.
But what happens when both are hitting all-time highs simultaneously?
This rare and fascinating convergence was the subject of a recent, insightful discussion on the Della Kambon show at ITM Trading, featuring host Danny and guest Joel Litman, a finance professor and Chief Investment Strategist at Ultimatry.
Litman explains that this unprecedented dual peak—a phenomenon that has occurred only six times since the 1970s—is not a glitch in the simulation. It’s a powerful signal driven by fundamentally separate forces, demanding a new level of diversification from investors.
The simultaneous ascent of gold and the S&P 500 paints a contradictory picture of the current global economy:
Gold has experienced an explosive surge, rising 44% this year and nearing the significant milestone of $4,000 an ounce. This movement is a classic reflection of global fear and systemic uncertainty.
Meanwhile, the S&P 500 has climbed 14% to set new records. This surge is predicated on a narrative of optimism surrounding U.S. corporate performance.
The contradiction resolves when you stop viewing the market as a single engine. Litman stresses that gold and stocks are being propelled by entirely different—but equally powerful—engines.
Gold is thriving because of global risk and instability. Stocks are thriving because of specific, idiosyncratic strength within the U.S. corporate sector.
“Gold is the hedge against global crisis and instability. Stocks are the reward for U.S. corporate innovation and strong earnings growth,” Litman explained.
A persistent critique of the current stock rally is that it’s purely dependent on a handful of mega-cap tech companies (the “Magnificent 7”). Litman thoroughly refutes this notion, providing evidence that the market’s strength is far broader than headlines suggest.
He revealed that over 400 stocks in the S&P 500 have more than doubled in value this year.
This breadth signals that the rally is robust and driven by genuine productivity gains across various sectors, not just concentrated momentum in tech giants. This reality opens up significant opportunities for selective stock pickers willing to look beyond the largest market caps.
Another source of investor confusion is the disconnect between mixed economic surveys (weak PMI, consumer spending concerns) and the strong performance of corporate earnings.
Litman clarifies that economic growth and corporate earnings growth are not synonymous. Many American companies can generate high economic profit even when the broader economy faces headwinds.
This resilience is largely attributed to the robust discretionary income of the U.S. consumer compared to consumers in other developed nations.
When assessing the risk of a prolonged bear market, Litman points to the historical precedence: bear markets almost always coincide with corporate credit crises.
Critically, the U.S. currently exhibits low credit risk. Conversely, Litman highlights that credit risks are perilously concentrated in China, where many companies—when reviewed under Western accounting standards—are barely profitable or effectively insolvent. This fundamental contrast supports a relatively optimistic view on the trajectory of U.S. equities.
The discussion also touched on global efforts to challenge the U.S. dollar’s dominance, including Russia’s financial strain and China’s strategic shifts, such as the proposed “China super monetary highway” involving gold trading in Hong Kong and Saudi Arabia.
While acknowledging these shifts, Litman remains skeptical that the complex structural and political hurdles facing these nations will allow them to unseat the USD’s dominance anytime soon.
The convergence of record-high gold and stocks is not a signal to panic, nor is it a sign to go all-in on one asset class. Instead, it underscores the profound importance of intelligent diversification.
This moment in history—where two opposing forces of the financial world hit their zenith together—is rare. It provides a unique opportunity for investors to hedge their global risks while capitalizing on the extraordinary strength and innovation of the U.S. corporate sector.